GC2 numbers off?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • TorchRedRob
    replied
    Originally posted by Js1010 View Post
    Gc2 - find yardages good overall except when you get in a lower spin range for a given club. So sub 2k for Driver will yield longer carry than I think is real. I see this myself as I tend to hit up on my driver and get a lot of low spin drives. You can also look at just about any Rick Shiels driver video on youtube.
    +1 on this. I usually spin it about 2100-2700, and last night I totally duffed one with low ball speed and only 1700 spin. I thought I'd be lucky to fly it 200yds. Jnpg algorithm said 189 carry while the GC2 readout said 244! I laughed. It would be nice if they'd adjust the algorithm on the low spinners.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ironstrokes
    replied
    Originally posted by Taylor40299 View Post
    Update. I raised the GC2 about an inch above the hitting surface today. It increased yardage by about 10 yards a club. An inlaw came over today to check it out because I was complaining about distances. His shot were a club short as well. We tried raising the unit and both noticed an difference immediately. If you factor in sea level for a few yards as well I think it is very close. When I'm in Florida I feel a about a 3/4 club short. I would post my numbers but don't now how to get pic into thread. As I mentioned before could not get my 5 wood to carry more than about 203. Now I carry it 230. Short and mid irons did not see but about 10 yard increase.
    Interesting results with just that little change. Ill have to give raising the GC2 up a go myself and see what happens. Have it a tiny bit above mat height right now.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ironstrokes
    replied
    Originally posted by Js1010 View Post
    Here are Optimal Flight numbers for your shot - basically same carry as GC2. You have great ballspeed for a 5W or even a 3W and should be hitting it 25yds further. The problem is your backspin at 5k is causing low carry. I also showed where this shot would carry if you dropped your spin down. Seeing your ballsped, I am sure you hit it a lot further on occasions when you don't hit down and create so much backspin.

    Also here is a Trackman PGA TOur Average that shows some averages for each club. You shold pay attention to ballspeed and the spin rates for each club when you are quesetioning your numbers.
    Thank you again, that's crazy that optimal flight is that different, but it's dead on again to what I'm seeing it seems

    ​​​​​​Makes sense with the spin being up that high getting those carry numbers.

    On a different note I have no idea how these dudes launch angles are that low, the only way I get them anywhere near those numbers is when I feel like I'm hitting a punch stinger shot and even then it may be exactly on the average, not much lower. So that could also be part of my iron woes. A normal 9 iron for me is much more than the 20 degree average they are getting, hell my 7 iron is usually a little higher than 20 degrees often too i think.

    Flightscope shot analyzer seems busted and way off now. Someone isnt calculating something right somewhere. I guess when its free you cant expect it to be perfect though

    Leave a comment:


  • Taylor40299
    replied
    I think I finally got this uploaded. This is my new data since raising the GC2 and inch above ball surface. 5 wood. After looking at the second chart I unfortunately am hitting the ball with launch numbers very similar to the "pros". BUT it appears that is probably to low to get for best carry distances. Trust me I am no pro and don't mean to imply any thing of the sort. Just know that most people I play with think I'm longer than most and hit it high. My PW numbers were 110 and launched at less than 29 degrees. Seemed low for a 48 degree club. Definitely and quickly learning to appreciate the numbers the GC2 gives. Complete bonus for me. I bought because I believed it to be the best choice for my application.
    Last edited by Taylor40299; 02-26-2017, 03:22 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Taylor40299
    commented on 's reply
    I loved that chart I would have to admit I do think I am hitting it lower inside than I do outside. Just a feeling but the launch numbers seem low. I think I might be a little closed at impact and maybe steep. I'm afraid of hitting ceiling and the s word. Don't have up protection yet. And yes I have done some miner damage. Drywall is easy to fix. Going to paint and carpet any way. Just trying to find the best spot to permanently set up sim.

  • Taylor40299
    commented on 's reply
    Update. I raised the GC2 about an inch above the hitting surface today. It increased yardage by about 10 yards a club. An inlaw came over today to check it out because I was complaining about distances. His shot were a club short as well. We tried raising the unit and both noticed an difference immediately. If you factor in sea level for a few yards as well I think it is very close. When I'm in Florida I feel a about a 3/4 club short. I would post my numbers but don't now how to get pic into thread. As I mentioned before could not get my 5 wood to carry more than about 203. Now I carry it 230. Short and mid irons did not see but about 10 yard increase.

  • Js1010
    replied
    Here are Optimal Flight numbers for your shot - basically same carry as GC2. You have great ballspeed for a 5W or even a 3W and should be hitting it 25yds further. The problem is your backspin at 5k is causing low carry. I also showed where this shot would carry if you dropped your spin down. Seeing your ballsped, I am sure you hit it a lot further on occasions when you don't hit down and create so much backspin.

    Also here is a Trackman PGA TOur Average that shows some averages for each club. You shold pay attention to ballspeed and the spin rates for each club when you are quesetioning your numbers.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ironstrokes
    replied
    Was curious on my 5 wood and heres and example i just got. I know its flightscope again and not optimal flight, but they are really that different? Jeez


    Click image for larger version

Name:	9.jpg
Views:	925
Size:	109.8 KB
ID:	107218

    Click image for larger version

Name:	10.jpg
Views:	565
Size:	179.3 KB
ID:	107219

    Leave a comment:


  • Ironstrokes
    replied
    Originally posted by Snaphook View Post
    A good way to test is to have a friend standing on a green you are hitting in to. After each shot he can go over to the pitchmark and laser the distance to you.
    This can be done with a driver aswell. Just make sure you are on a level hole and there is no wind. (Depending on your skill level you might want to give him a helmet :-)
    I find the GC2 very accurate, except the really low spin drives, wich are overestimated in carry.

    Haha maybe only on a really good day I can peg him down.

    Yea I'm definitely gonna try this at some point soon. It's tough to get a spot where their is practically 0 wind. And that's what I'm really gonna need to have to check if there really is a 3-7 yard short discrepancy. 7 yards is fairly noticeable, but most of my shots are in the 3-5 yard short territory, definitely tougher to notice.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ironstrokes
    replied
    Originally posted by Js1010 View Post
    Post your launch numbers of a 5W that should have gone 235 but only 200 on GC2. Is this in FR1 or are you getting same numbers on the GC2 itself? By the way you can press the gc2 speaker so it will speak out the numbers while its connected to Fr1.
    I'm curious the numbers he's getting there as well. I definitely see a similar situation as him with the irons. The 5 wood seemed to be ok with the read outs for me. It did still feel a little short compared to the skytrak and what I expected it would go. But not a 30 yard difference I don't believe. But have been more obsessed with my iron and driver testing recently, so gotta take a closer look at the fairway woods personally

    Leave a comment:


  • Snaphook
    replied
    A good way to test is to have a friend standing on a green you are hitting in to. After each shot he can go over to the pitchmark and laser the distance to you.
    This can be done with a driver aswell. Just make sure you are on a level hole and there is no wind. (Depending on your skill level you might want to give him a helmet :-)
    I find the GC2 very accurate, except the really low spin drives, wich are overestimated in carry.


    Leave a comment:


  • Snaphook
    commented on 's reply
    Please post your launch numbers. Maybe something is wrong with your unit? I have FR1 myself and the distances in the software are exactly the same as on the gc2 itself.

  • Js1010
    commented on 's reply
    Post your launch numbers of a 5W that should have gone 235 but only 200 on GC2. Is this in FR1 or are you getting same numbers on the GC2 itself? By the way you can press the gc2 speaker so it will speak out the numbers while its connected to Fr1.

  • Ironstrokes
    replied
    Originally posted by FaultyClubs View Post

    Can't determine anything with range balls. See this for example: http://www.golfdigest.com/story/gd-tested-range-balls
    Wow! 165 - 215 range on a 7 iron test with range balls! Yea scratch the range test of being that useful.

    But even if it is flying 200 yards or whatever, if i can somehow mark that spot exactly then I'd still know if the gc2 was a little short in its readings...but like you said, the wind for only a 5 yards difference is probably gonna be impossible to tell at any reasonable distance

    Leave a comment:


  • Ironstrokes
    replied
    Originally posted by Taylor40299 View Post
    Gc2 is not accurate on distances. Have been checking with laser and gps. In my situation, it's off by a club or more. I can't hit my 5 wood more than 203 carry on gc2. On the course it's my 235 to 250 club. I use it on a par 4 that is 245 and have often landed on the fly. IRL Full pitching wedge is 130, not killed. Can barely get a 9 iron 130 Cary on gc2. Very accurate on ball flight. I'd be happy to know what's not right. I'm using FR1.
    Exactly the way I feel with my distance on it! Good to see others feel the same way. Hate having to possibly boost any clubs, not going that route until I'm desperate and know 100 percent if it's actually short or not

    Leave a comment:

Working...