New optishot purchase

[Bilbo]

I'd recommend Rmotion over optishot. IMO, it's way more consistent, and gives more accurate results. I've used both.

Thanks, I am taking a good hard look at it now. Seems like a better solution with exception that it would be more cumbersome for my kids or buddies to come over and play. I need to pull the trigger one way or another when I have the funds. If I don't I'll end up with a new set of clubs.

[Chuck]

I have just the opposite opinion. I've owned both, and the Optishot seems far more reliable and frankly a little more enjoyable. I prefer the Optishot game to TGC game because course replications seemed better and the optishot has on-line play, where as TGC with R-motion doesn't. Second optishot is near realtime. R-motion is swing and then wait a few seconds to see the results. I had a lot of frustration with my R-motion and never completed a single course without something happening. I've had some missed swings with optishot but it's always worked.

[Jb50]

I'm surprised you had so much of a delay after hitting the ball. Mine is less than a second. Pretty much the same as Optishot.

[Lgnir]

I have a SkyTrak, but I bought an OptiShot 2 so I could play with my grandkids without worrying about someone bashing a club into a $2000 unit! I my opinion, I rank the SkyTrak way higher in accuracy. Shots I know should slice badly are more like a gentle fade on the OptiShot. My club distances are much longer on the OptiShot as well. My biggest complaint is having to tape my clubs to get good readings, then ripping the tape off to play real golf, then taping them again to use the OptiShot.

I do like the fact that the OptiShot is fun for my grandkids and it's getting them into golf! Being able to play the courses as par 3's makes it even much more fun for them. However, if you are really looking to improve your golf game, save your money and get a real launch monitor, where you can get some good, accurate data. I love my SkyTrak and TGC, and it has helped my real life golf game HUGELY!

[Chuck]

The one area that optishot has an advantage over R-motion (maybe skytrack) is the real-time response. The R-motion with it's sensors and bluetooth communications will add 3 seconds from your swing impact to the time action occurs on the screen. It doesn't take much to see this in youtube videos. Skytrack did the same in videos I've seen with TGC. I really wanted to like the R-motion and TGC, but my device broke open on a swing, it would loose communication way to much and then there was http://store.steampowered.com/app/269730/The_Golf_Club, for $39.99 and then you look at the $499 R-motion TGC upgrade (to the so called full-version). What do you get, a diamond studded USB key?!?!? I mean really? What kind of pricing model is that?
I really enjoyed the R-motion when it worked (for me that was rare). I may try it again later but for now, I'm enjoying optishot on 1920x1280 projection screen in great detail and it's sweet.

[ProTee United]

We are not seeing 3 second delays Chuck.

There is really no need to constantly bash R-Motion in all your posts, just because "you" had some weird problems with it. You requested and received a full refund.

[Chuck]

Your right. I've said all I need to say on R-motion. There are many positives in R-motion, like not having to tape clubs or having to build a stance mat. I liked the TGC user interface better than Opti's. When the next version comes out, I may give it a try again. It's been interesting learning all of the factors that go into a good simulator. Like all technologies, they will improve over time, and with VR being adopted so quickly, that might be were we are heading in the future.

[Chuck]

Just a follow up no. R-motion's support services was really good. I had many good back-and-forth emails with Rapsodo on my issues With him on board, I'm confident R-motion will make waves in the simulator game market. On the games side, the price model is odd (in my opinion).