Fiberbuilt v CCE

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Mike80
    replied
    Hey, check out the thread I just created about creating your own real feel golf turf mat. Try this. You will love the results!

    I wanted to share the latest golf sim project I just finished. I wanted to make my golf mat feel a little softer and more like hitting down in the ground

    Leave a comment:


  • jwest68
    replied
    Originally posted by goatbarn View Post
    I have a CCE 5' x 5' and enjoy the feedback it gives when I hit one fat. I want to be penalized for hitting fat, otherwise I won't get the feedback I need to make changes that I would otherwise see out on the course IRL.

    I think it's amazing.
    Totally agree. I have no problems with my wrist, shoulders, or elbows and I use my CCE about 3-4 times a week. For what it's worth, I've got a DW Quail 4x5 mat that is 4 months old that I would sell for $110 plus shipping from the Tulsa area. I prefer my CCE over the DW mat

    Leave a comment:


  • Vincent_Vega
    replied
    Originally posted by Psw757 View Post

    I only asked because all the fiberbuilt mats I've seen have large irregular ball holders which I thought might make leveling the Skytrak difficult.
    Gotcha. I don't have that issue because I just inserted 2 FB panels in to my existing hitting platform. I'm sure the ball tray would create an issue. I would imagine though that the ball tray could be removed.

    Leave a comment:


  • Vincent_Vega
    replied
    Originally posted by Shardak View Post
    VV: I think you had an issue with putting on the fiberbuilt. Are you learning to live with it? It seems like a very brushy style of surface, not as dense as CCE, so I have some doubts about how well it will be with putting.

    But I just lost 1 week of practice due to elbow pain which I am pretty sure is from hitting on the CCE, so I am considering Fiberbuilt or TrueStrike
    I still personally am not crazy about putting off the FB vs the CCE. I find it uncomfortable when addressing the ball. It seems the putter head wants to move or shift because of the bristles giving way a tad.

    Leave a comment:


  • Psw757
    replied
    Originally posted by Vincent_Vega View Post

    The same as any other mat. Just set it on something that puts it level with your hitting surface. This goes for any mat or stance platform you use.
    I only asked because all the fiberbuilt mats I've seen have large irregular ball holders which I thought might make leveling the Skytrak difficult.

    Leave a comment:


  • Shardak
    commented on 's reply
    VV: I think you had an issue with putting on the fiberbuilt. Are you learning to live with it? It seems like a very brushy style of surface, not as dense as CCE, so I have some doubts about how well it will be with putting.

    But I just lost 1 week of practice due to elbow pain which I am pretty sure is from hitting on the CCE, so I am considering Fiberbuilt or TrueStrike

  • Vincent_Vega
    replied
    Originally posted by Psw757 View Post
    I haven't seen anyone comment on placement of the Skytrak unit when using a 5x5 fiberbuilt mat.
    The same as any other mat. Just set it on something that puts it level with your hitting surface. This goes for any mat or stance platform you use.

    Leave a comment:


  • Psw757
    replied
    Originally posted by Vincent_Vega View Post

    That was before we discovered the USB connection issue. After connecting via wifi, the FB performs exactly the same as my CCE. No difference whatsoever. All shots are picked up by the Skytrak.
    I haven't seen anyone comment on placement of the Skytrak unit when using a 5x5 fiberbuilt mat.

    Leave a comment:


  • Vincent_Vega
    replied
    Originally posted by aja View Post
    I believe that someone posted that SkyTrak does not work well with Fiberbuilt mats. Maybe they can chime in.
    That was before we discovered the USB connection issue. After connecting via wifi, the FB performs exactly the same as my CCE. No difference whatsoever. All shots are picked up by the Skytrak.

    Leave a comment:


  • N54TT
    commented on 's reply
    AJA, that poster was Vincent_Vega and he later posted out that he figured out what the problem was......ball placement.

  • FaultyClubs
    commented on 's reply
    Id agree ball and hitting surface friction most be some factor.

    Also the ball may have been still on the club when the club contacted the mat or grass. Who knows how an amateur 2 hdcp really hits the ball.

    And we all know how psychology of hitting environment affects our swing. He may swing differently on grass versus mat.

    The test has several variables and they didn't control any of them so it's meaningless. It's funny how the human mind will still draw conclusions from meaningless tests though. The real value of this discussion is to highlight the variables to control if we were to do a useful test.

  • mmlincon
    commented on 's reply
    Even if you hit the ball first you are still impacting a surface that doesn't give much. It's almost like always hitting off hard pan all the time, not quite that bad but...

    I received the TrueStirke and played two simulator rounds on it and it feels WAY better than the CCE. And that is with my stance mat being about 1/2-3/4" lower than the hitting surface. I liked it so much I've ordered the rest of their mat sections. It feels so much more like hitting off of real turf to me.

    FWIW, TrueStrike was tested with the Trackman and showed only a 3% difference vs the 12% with other mats. - this is from proputtssystems website so take that as you will

    At the end of the day it all depends on what you like. I noticed some negative things happening with my swing using the CCE so I went in search of something different. Time will tell how the TrueStrike works out.

  • wbond
    replied
    I have the Apex irons as well, and have no problems holding greens outside, but when playing on TGC, there is a lot more roll out. i tend to chip alot from back of greens.

    Leave a comment:


  • Shardak
    replied
    Originally posted by mthunt View Post
    Just curious but the CCE is the gold standard in mats. In fact Trackman even used it in comparing Mats to grass (below). If you hit it fat you lose distance. Isn't it good to working on hitting it solid? The fibre built is really forgiving. Maybe too much?


    http://blog.trackmangolf.com/mats-vs...ts-difference/

    Wow great info in that article. 2k less spin with a 7 iron hitting off a mat. I would never have thought it made that much difference.

    I recently got new clubs (Callaway Apex CF) which are low spinning by design or so I have read. I have been a little concerned with the really low spin numbers I see when hitting in my simulator (Skytrak / CCE mat). Playing TGC, it is hard to hold greens with a 7i or lower club. But when I play in real life, I hold greens pretty good.

    Glad to see that maybe some of the low spin I see is due to the mat. I think the rest of the issue lies in TGC, where some greens just feel like ice on approach shots. I notice that even playing the Xbox version..its just a quirk with the physics of the game I guess.

    Leave a comment:


  • mthunt
    commented on 's reply
    It must be the friction between the mat and the ball at contact.
Working...