Xi+ first impression

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Brutaly
    replied
    Originally posted by jon.summy@aol.com View Post
    Brutaly......anxiously awaiting how you calculate path and face angle......I really appreciate all of your input it is great food for thought. This is making me strongly consider pulling the trigger on a Xi+. Thank you!
    Download Trajectoware and you are good to go. Its that easy.

    Just input the values you got from the Xi+.

    Just remember to multiply horizontal launch angle with 0,85 for woods and 0,75 for irons to get a correct face to target line.

    Leave a comment:


  • Brutaly
    replied
    Have tons to do so here comes a short answer on how to fit with Xi.

    Calculate angle of attack according to my previous post. There are tools you can buy and setup to determine launch angle, i know Wishon Golf sold one version of it and if you browse the Internet you can find other tools as well. Its a mechanical device you setup.

    Pinpoint a target approx 100 meters out on the range. Use this target for all shots.

    Use a compass and identify 2 reference points, one of each side of the target, which should be 5 degrees angle from the target. A good compass will have no issues doing this but dont have your bag to close when doing it.

    Stand right behind the one you are fitting and see to it that they are properly lined up, which you have to do with a full blown LM anyway.

    Determine each shot starting direction in relation to the target line. Dont stare at the ball, look at the reference points.

    Jolt down the perceived angle of each shot and the number of the shot. Exclude the same shots that you exclude from the FS data when evaluating.

    Calculate the mean value. If you practice for 30 minutes you can get this down to +/- 1 degree. Multiply by 85% on woods and 75% on irons and hybrids. Now you got face to target.

    Open up Trajectoware and take data from the Xi and fill in the blanks.

    Check the carry distance and the lateral deviation.

    Open up trajectoware and manipulate the shape of the curve so that your calculated face to target and the landing spot correlates with your calculations. This little trick will give you a proper face to path and club path.

    That is pretty much it.

    Oh, if you fit with Xi i suggest that you start out with irons and move to woods and let the second longest wood determine the baseline for driver loft. If you do it in that order you dont have to worry about launch angles and AoA as much until you start with the driver. The driver should have 4-6 degrees lower loft compared to the second longest wood. If you can hit the second longest wood of the deck with a good trajectory your driver loft will be good enough as a baseline. A club that cant be hit off the deck consistently is basically just an other driver.

    Invaluable when fitting drivers.
    http://wishongolf.com/wp-content/upl...ation_2010.pdf
    Read it thru and you realize you actually dont need the exact numbers from an LM
    Measure the current loft and start there.

    If you plan to fit professionally, buy the Xi+. For home fitting the Xi i enough.

    There is actually one even easier way.
    Read thru the Flightscope section of the forum and you will find a post stating that you could contact the poster if you want to maximize the value of you Xi. PM him and buy and android device. Just saying.
    Last edited by Brutaly; 02-26-2015, 10:23 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • jon.summy@aol.com
    replied
    Brutaly......anxiously awaiting how you calculate path and face angle......I really appreciate all of your input it is great food for thought. This is making me strongly consider pulling the trigger on a Xi+. Thank you!

    Leave a comment:


  • Brutaly
    replied
    Ok. I havent done any proper testing with GA and the Xi+.

    Just got access to a second Xi+ and will try to set them up side by side. One at the correct distance ofc.

    I know FS have had issues with radar interference when setup beside an other radar.

    Leave a comment:


  • Maverick
    replied
    GA estimates spin and spin axis last time I checked.

    Leave a comment:


  • goatbarn
    replied
    Doe's the data measured by both the FS and GA correlate? Does the data match closely?

    Leave a comment:


  • Brutaly
    replied
    What do you mean with numbers jive? Im not very familiar with english,,

    Leave a comment:


  • Bubba22
    replied
    But you find that the numbers jive with the Flightscope?

    Leave a comment:


  • Brutaly
    replied
    Originally posted by Bubba22 View Post
    Is that a Golfacheiver I see in the picture?
    Yeah, side spin is messed up and wedges are to long. Infact not so much the side spin as how it shapes the shot based on side spin.

    Mid irons work nicely on it so it will be those i have to do my testing with, i7 is pretty spot on with the Xi+.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bubba22
    replied
    Is that a Golfacheiver I see in the picture?

    Leave a comment:


  • Brutaly
    replied
    Originally posted by fhann View Post
    What would your minimum acceptable distances for fitting be for:

    distance from front of launch monitor to ball
    distance from ball to impact screen?

    What Flightscope recommends in the manual.

    I havent tested enough to be certain regarding the thresholds.

    For sim i suspect 150 cm from radar to ball and 250 cm from ball to screen. It might be good enough for simulations, at least with my 95 mph swingspeed. What seems to be messed up with shorter distance to the screen is mainly spin. Which means then higher the swingspeed the less accuracy in measuring spin.

    I didnt have the time to go in depth yesterday and today my Accusport was picked up by its new owner. So my future tests has to be based on comparing the simulator data with the flightscope data.

    B

    Leave a comment:


  • fhann
    replied
    What would your minimum acceptable distances for fitting be for:

    distance from front of launch monitor to ball
    distance from ball to impact screen?

    Leave a comment:


  • Brutaly
    replied
    I just wrote a post that adressed all questions and something got messed up when i pressed post and everything just disappeared. Sigh....

    So here comes the answers with out quoting etc.

    No i dont calibrate it each session, i have tape on the floor and a static tee so the values i use are the same from session to session. It might be wrong but i havent found anything stating that you need to recalibrate if the device is used in a static environment. But even if i had to recalibrate it takes no time at all.

    Optimal Flight or Trajectoware are nice softwares. I used optimal flight which is very affordable and get frequent updates.
    I just swapped to trajectoware which is free but get no updates but its really easy to use. I will stick with Trajectoware due to the ease when simulating path alterations.

    Yes i can explain how to fit with Xi and that was what i focused on in my post that got messed up. I will write a new post later this week that i will try to post correctly. :-)

    Angle of attack which is missing in Xi and which is needed for driver fitting. See the picture i attached. What you need to do is measuring the loft of the driver (which you need to do even if the LM has AoA.) to use the chart. Only use horisontal centerhits to eliminate the roll angle and exclude hooks and slices since those tend to manipulate the loft.

    I would use 85% on woods and 75% on irons when translating horisontal launch to face angle

    Apex. Just insert numbers from Xi in trajectoware. My next post regarding fitting with Xi will explain one way to get face angle and club path which is needed for a correct calculation in trajectoware.

    Dynamic loft=Static loft+(angle of attack)

    To be perfectly honest i find spin loft of less importance when it comes to fitting, its more of a swing issue and as such i just dont use it even though i adjust it with different shafts etc.. But to answer you, i dont know how to calculate that. Its the product of Static loft and AoA so the easy answer is SL=DL-AoA. By using different shafts you can affect then spin loft by approx +/-0,7 degree from the players baseline. Well calculating that is beyond my competence.
    When i fit i look more at launch angle, apex, angle of descent and ballflight so it suits the player. Apex, angle of descent and flight is after all the effect of the dynamic loft. Dont get me wrong, its superimportant but knowing how to calculate it exactly isnt worth the time.

    Here is an other take on it which is basicall what you wrote:
    Spin Loft = Dynamic Loft - Angle of Attack
    Dynamic Loft = Spin Loft + Angle of Attack

    It might not be scientifically exact but its good enough.In general i think people look to much at the numbers but know very little on how to change them, both in their swing and in their equipment.

    This link is the one i have found that really explains it well.
    http://www.golfwrx.com/204625/get-a-...-of-spin-loft/


    I found the launch numbers to stack up compared with the Accusport.

    Sidenote, i included a pic that shows you how close i used it yesterday with acceptable (compared to the simulator which i have no clue regarding its validity) data. Thats about 60 inches. It wasnt acceptable for fitting but for simulator gameplay i wouldnt hesitate one second. There were some anomalies but for sim use i could really live with it.
    Attached Files
    Last edited by Brutaly; 02-23-2015, 11:27 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • goatbarn
    replied
    Great write up.

    I concur with your review, although I have an Xi. IMO, great investment.

    Leave a comment:


  • Skedaddle
    replied
    Oh and finally, how did the Launch angle numbers from Accusport stack up against Flightscope? Were they pretty bang on?

    Leave a comment:

Working...