Originally posted by fhann
View Post
Xi+ first impression
Collapse
X
-
Not that I'm aware of. The ball data is collected all the time but what can be collected diminishes during the flight. From what I understand in outdoor range testing they use a second unit down range facing the robot and by combining the data from both units they are capable of getting all data.
-
But very strictly spoken the claim that those sidebands are usable have until now not been confirmed. The sideband data resolution in the images I saw are not such that those are usable and the long range ball data and the values presented show problems in determine that data.Originally posted by FaultyClubs View PostStrictly speaking the radar doesn't need a sticker, the ball itself generates enough signal return to produce the frequency sidebands needed to measure spin but indoors the time bandwidth product is so low the signal isn't strong enough to be reliably differentiated from noise so they add a radar reflector (ie metallic sticker) to enhance the signal.
Given doppler frequency sidebands are weak relative to the total radar return, the sticker would be critical for measuring spin rate but not so much for the other stuff.
Leave a comment:
-
The ball data is measured all the time downrange if the ball is not obscured by a hill or other large object(s). Windspeed does not increase nor decrease the ball spin. It affects the flight of the ball because the net affect of windspeed and it's direction induces the ball to perform like the ball either spins more or less because the net drag/lift is is more/less depending upon wind strength and direction. So the ball is measured and its position is recorded. It shows this position, trajectory, etc. as an actual measurement. Flightscope and Trackman have an option to input actual wind and barometric conditions that are being experienced outdoors and the operator can select an option to normalize the ball flight, so the modelling software takes over and produces a ball flight that would occur without wind.Last edited by fhann; 03-01-2015, 11:10 PM.
Leave a comment:
-
But indoors FaultyClubs a sticker is recommended for better data, right? Can I ask how the units take wind dtc in to account when used outdoors?
Leave a comment:
-
Strictly speaking the radar doesn't need a sticker, the ball itself generates enough signal return to produce the frequency sidebands needed to measure spin but indoors the time bandwidth product is so low the signal isn't strong enough to be reliably differentiated from noise so they add a radar reflector (ie metallic sticker) to enhance the signal.Originally posted by Dax View Post
I agree with a lot of this, but wonder then why TM would say, "In order to receive measured spin rates, a Special metallic sticker Must be placed on the golf ball." Not sure why they would say this if it were not helping them in some way measure spin.
Given doppler frequency sidebands are weak relative to the total radar return, the sticker would be critical for measuring spin rate but not so much for the other stuff.
Leave a comment:
-
They could use the stronger signal the metal dot is giving. No idea if they would, the TM uses the flight length to determine if you are using the unit indoor or outdoor so maybe they also use that to switch calculations routines. No idea what the FS is doing.Originally posted by Bubba22 View PostSo even outdoors the metal dot improves the ball data?
But in general metal dot will, like indoor, make the ball signal to stand out more. Might however be that over the longer flight that metal dot, even if it is very light and thin, skew the down range aerodynamic ball behavior
Maybe hitting several balls with and without metal dot and then compare data would give an indication. It's possible to get the full carry length data set from the TM so maybe there is an indication there in that data set to be found, never tried that.... yet .....
Leave a comment:
-
The metal dot will not improve measurements outdoors because the TM or Flightscope launch monitor keeps measuring ball data downrange. That dot will artificially affect spin, drag and flight characteristics down range, i.e. similar to how mud on a ball or a knick in the cover will affect the ball flight. Indoors, the ball does not have time to be substantially affected/slowed by additional drag. The ball behaves more like a ballistic object during the first 20 to 30 feet before spin starts to influence lift.Last edited by fhann; 03-01-2015, 10:38 PM.
Leave a comment:
-
I don't know but if I would take an educated guess I would say it's needed indoor to measure spin and spin-axis tilt data and also used to improve launch angles and speed measurements data.Originally posted by Bubba22 View PostClubfitter, what parameters are the metal dot mainly required for? Is it spin, launch angle, side angle? The reason I ask is the smaller units like the ES14 etc require no melt dot but ar obviously limited in what they measure.
Leave a comment:
-
But the launch monitor, such as Trackman, desires more than 1 sample, i.e. minimally it needs to see/detect the dot twice. The sample size may need to be more than 2 depending upon software/firmware coupled with equipment sensitivity/accuracy along with signal to noise ratio, etc. Flightscope is very similar.
Clubfitter73 has also reminded us that detection occurs within a cone for both the ball and clubhead detection analyses.
Leave a comment:
-
Clubfitter, what parameters are the metal dot mainly required for? Is it spin, launch angle, side angle? The reason I ask is the smaller units like the ES14 etc require no melt dot but ar obviously limited in what they measure.
Leave a comment:
-
Yes, the metal dot is needed to improve signal to noise level. But that has nothing to do with what I wroteOriginally posted by FaultyClubs View PostA Doppler radar doesn't work that way. The spinning dot cause a frequency shift around the doppler centroid (ball velocity), this frequency shift is then measured to determine spin rate. The resolution of the frequency shift is determined by the effective doppler bandwidth and the accuracy by the signal to noise. There are many ways to implement this but none actually "count" the number of revolutions of the ball! The problem indoors is signal to noise (limited signal and lots of clutter) hence the metal dot. The metal dot is included to improve the signal to noise (not to be counted). But even so I doubt indoor spin measurements would be as accurate as outdoor.
If the metal dots is not visible (present) in the radar beam then the radar was little change to pick up the signal in a short flight. So if the speed and spin are such that the dot is never visible (present) there is no spin data. That is what I wrote.
I only did the rotations per flight calculations to show to the readers how short that time of flight is and that even a high a spin as 5000rpm during that short time of flight almost no rotation is left for the radar to measure.
If the DSP is good enough then maybe during the half a rotation the metal data is visible for the radar there might be enough data points present to calculate the spin, then that single (or technically a 1/2 ) rotation would be enough however the error margin on that spin value will be rather high. Also during the initial part of the flight the impact generates so much noise that a part of that signal is lost. For TM the absolute minimum is 2 rotations.
PS Imho long range indoor (metal dot) data is much better then outdoor (non metal dot) data.
PSS I tested <$5 radar panels and using the count method (as the ADC resolution was not good enough) it was possible to get within 10rpm of the TM data IF the number of rotations was sufficient.Last edited by Clubfitter73; 03-01-2015, 08:42 PM.
Leave a comment:
-
I agree with a lot of this, but wonder then why TM would say, "In order to receive measured spin rates, a Special metallic sticker Must be placed on the golf ball." Not sure why they would say this if it were not helping them in some way measure spin.Originally posted by FaultyClubs View Post
A Doppler radar doesn't work that way. The spinning dot cause a frequency shift around the doppler centroid (ball velocity), this frequency shift is then measured to determine spin rate. The resolution of the frequency shift is determined by the effective doppler bandwidth and the accuracy by the signal to noise. There are many ways to implement this but none actually "count" the number of revolutions of the ball! The problem indoors is signal to noise (limited signal and lots of clutter) hence the metal dot. The metal dot is included to improve the signal to noise (not to be counted). But even so I doubt indoor spin measurements would be as accurate as outdoor.
Leave a comment:
-
A Doppler radar doesn't work that way. The spinning dot cause a frequency shift around the doppler centroid (ball velocity), this frequency shift is then measured to determine spin rate. The resolution of the frequency shift is determined by the effective doppler bandwidth and the accuracy by the signal to noise. There are many ways to implement this but none actually "count" the number of revolutions of the ball! The problem indoors is signal to noise (limited signal and lots of clutter) hence the metal dot. The metal dot is included to improve the signal to noise (not to be counted). But even so I doubt indoor spin measurements would be as accurate as outdoor.Originally posted by Clubfitter73 View PostWhen the spin on that same ball is 5000 rpm (rotations per minute) or 83.3 rotations per second that 0.074 will allow the ball to rotate 6.2 times. at 290cm 4.5 rotations. As the metal dot can only be measured while facing the radar that 6.2 can easily become 5 rotations measured and that 4.5 easily only 3 rotations measured.
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: