Number of putts on TGC 2019

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 3on3putt
    replied
    Originally posted by mthunt View Post

    I can tell what people have gimmies set to. Just PM me the name and I’ll check. If they are not using the right settings I’ll deal with them.
    Right. I guess what I'm saying is that it would be great if there was a way to set it up so people could not even tee off to start a tournament if all the settings weren't correct. Like an algorithm in the game that would block you from even entering the event without the correct settings.

    In any case, the person in question isn't hard to find. He's one of the small handful of guys under par (gross) for the Zozo.

    And while we're at it, there's also another guy who has 2 putts for 36 holes. He's currently leading the net portion of the event.

    And a third guy who has 0 putts for 36 holes. He's in the top 5 for net.

    And a quick look at their player profiles shows that they aren't new to the tours either. One of them has played in dozens of events. Which means they've likely been doing this all along.

    That's 3 guys right there, just on a quick search of the leaderboard. Several other questionable ones too. Which is why I say it would be great if there was a way to block these people from ever entering the events in the first place.

    Is the boost max also just based on an honor system? Me thinks that if guys are cheating on the gimmies than they are also probably cheating on the boost.
    Last edited by 3on3putt; 10-25-2020, 04:58 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • mthunt
    replied
    Originally posted by 3on3putt View Post
    I wish there was a way for the game to not allow people in the tournaments who do not have their settings correct rather than it just being an honor system, which makes me wonder how many people are shaving strokes by setting gimmies to 8 feet or 10 feet or something that wouldn't stick out as so plainly obvious as this one. Is the boost max also just based on an honor system as well?
    I can tell what people have gimmies set to. Just PM me the name and I’ll check. If they are not using the right settings I’ll deal with them.

    Leave a comment:


  • mthunt
    commented on 's reply
    Will, I’m betting you had more than 3 putt listed in your 4 below handicap. LOL.

  • Wizard of Coz
    commented on 's reply
    Yeah it's tricky with the gimmie gators but they can be caught by playing their 👻 or looking at their shot recording.
    They should have some putts between 6-12 ft the settings can be found if you go to the players profile look under all shots then all the way to the right tap the blue icon.
    Last edited by Wizard of Coz; 10-25-2020, 03:01 AM.

  • Wizard of Coz
    commented on 's reply
    It was a crazy good back nine. Thanks. That was back when i played all the time. I'm just getting back into it again. Hopefully there are some more 50s ahead.

  • Will
    commented on 's reply
    Very nice round.

  • Will
    commented on 's reply
    That text was exaggerated for a colorful bit of emphasis. Maybe it should be deleted. I really have fun playing and haven't really thought much about the leaderboard, except that I enjoy watching rank later in the round. It's a great feature to see how you relatively stack up.

    I remove my hat in real life. 57 is a video game score.

    To your point, I shot 4 under my real handicap today online and didn't strike the ball particularly well. A chip went in, and that happens much more often on tgc2019 than real life.
    I sank a 20 foot putt on 18 and I believe placed two 60 foot putts within a couple feet of the pin. I instantly found my ball in the 2' rough, twice, and then hit it onto the green. Didn't catch my club at all. I hit a wood about 180 yards out of the sand, even though I got under it. That's not happening where I play, yet somehow it all worked out well online.

    You are right. Sorry to derail the putting conversation with PGA stats as a perspective. My putting is outstanding on the sim vs real life.

    Peace be with you.

  • Wizard of Coz
    replied
    Will here is one.
    Last edited by Wizard of Coz; 10-25-2020, 02:46 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Wizard of Coz
    commented on 's reply
    There are lots of 50 rounds out there if the course is short or the greens are easy to putt. I have like 4 rounds in the 50s. Marc Andre and Nick have equal or more. Noonan this past week had like 4 rounds in the 50s and i watched one live on discord video.
    Last edited by Wizard of Coz; 10-25-2020, 02:45 AM.

  • 3on3putt
    commented on 's reply
    @Will

    That's some sour grapes. Some things to consider here....

    1.) Everyone scores a little better on the sim once they get the hang of sim golf.

    2.) Most of the tournaments on the exhibition tour are played at around 6,000 yards or less. I believe that one in particular was only like 5,400 yards.

    Take a really good player in real life (a + handicapper) who is accustomed to shooting 70 or so from 6,700 yards.

    Now put them on a sim, where things are easier because of all the various advantages you have on a sim (perfect lie, perfect stance, 6 foot gimmies, etc. etc. etc.) That 70 becomes a 65.

    Now put them on a 5,400 yard course on a sim where they are hitting short irons into all the par 5's and driving it on or near the green on many of the par 4's. A lot of the par 4's on that course were setup at like 260 yards. Some of the par 5's were only like 430 yards. That 65 becomes a sub 60 round easily. Heck, par is basically like 65 on a course with that kind of setup.

    57 is easily realistic for a good player under those conditions. Even I shot under par in that tournament, and I'm a 7 handicap in real life.

    I would not accuse him of being a cheat. The guy with 5 putts for 36 holes? Yes. But the 57 with 15 (non-gimmie) putts? No. Stop comparing Jim Furyk and PGA Tour stats to sim golf played from 5,400 yards.

    And are you saying that if you played golf with someone who shot 57 you wouldn't even shake their hand after the round?? What??
    Last edited by 3on3putt; 10-24-2020, 08:39 PM.

  • Will
    commented on 's reply
    @3on3putt

    You are right.
    Last edited by Will; 10-25-2020, 01:57 AM.

  • 3on3putt
    replied
    I wish there was a way for the game to not allow people in the tournaments who do not have their settings correct rather than it just being an honor system, which makes me wonder how many people are shaving strokes by setting gimmies to 8 feet or 10 feet or something that wouldn't stick out as so plainly obvious as this one. Is the boost max also just based on an honor system as well?
    Last edited by 3on3putt; 10-24-2020, 06:32 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • 3on3putt
    commented on 's reply
    Will

    You're misinterpreting the stats. As has been noted above, the number of putts listed in the stats for TGC2019 are only the putts that you actually hit. It does not count the number of gimmies. So the guy who shot 57 with 15 putts only had 15 putts that he himself actually hit. So when you add in his gimmies he actually had likely 20+ putts for the round.

    In my hypothetical example where I tried to present a scenario where someone could have 3 putts, they actually would've had at least 18 putts by official putting stats.

    Your PGA stats are counting all putts. TGC putts only count putts outside of 6 feet.
    Last edited by 3on3putt; 10-24-2020, 06:32 PM.

  • mthunt
    commented on 's reply
    It’s not possible to have 3 putts in TGC. It’s 100% someone not playing by the rules.

  • Will
    commented on 's reply
    @3on3putt

    https://www.pga.com/archive/fewest-n...round-pga-tour

    As of 2018, only 8 pga players have had 18 putts during a round before. Think about that for a moment. All of those elite players playing nearly every weekend for decades and only 8. Also, most of those crazy rounds didn't play well against the field. Missed approach shots and chips that left them close.

    .....
    Last edited by Will; 10-25-2020, 02:00 AM.
Working...