SwingTurf

[myrison]

Hi all -- I've had the SwingTurf mat since November of last year. I originally ordered both a CCE and a ST mat to compare the two and the ST is easily a more forgiving yet realistic mat than the CCE. I kept them both for a couple of weeks and it was an easy choice for me. My swing type is sweeping, not digging, so I don't hit the ground hard or typically take big divots. I'm mid-40's in good shape otherwise, all of which is I think relevant to the best mat for a given person, so I wanted to mention it briefly.

Although I like the ST more than the CCE, I've now been hitting off the ST for a few months and have developed a gradually increasing wrist pain, and a growing amount of rib pain. The rib pain I don't think is mat-related, but I believe the wrist pain is. I've found myself searching here for a more forgiving mat (which was how I found this thread). The good news for the ST is that the wrist pain took a long time and a lot of reps to develop. I've admittedly been overdoing it, playing at least 18 holes a day, and some days 2x that. If you play less or have stronger joints, you may be just fine with the ST (the reviews on the site for it are great).

Like others have said in the thread, I really think you need to check these out yourself as everyone's experience and swing type will affect their ideal mat. Hopefully this helps you make your decision. I'm thinking about trying the Quattro mat but am waiting for it to go back on sale as mentioned in the other thread on the topic.

[gohandbz8]

I purchased this mat and got to try out a few shots with it. For comparison, I bought the Net Return hitting mat which was pretty thin and did not provide much cushioning so I put some exercise foam mats underneath for relief.

As for the swing turf, I did not need to put any foam mats underneath it and it feels much better already. Unfortunately, my GC2 is currently out of commission and being serviced so I dont know how this mat affects my ball data. I do like the fact that you can put real tees in it, even though I will probably still use the bir-tee. Once I get my GC2 back up and running, I'll play a few rounds and report back to see if I notice any wrist pain or golfer's elbow.

[elnino74]

Hello. So, I also have the Net Return hitting mat, which I've been using for about six months. I now have some pain in my right elbow / forearm, and I am looking for solutions. I am also wondering if the simplest solution would be to just place some thicker foam interlocking tiles under the Net Return mat to essentially make the surface softer.

I'm curious to hear if this solution worked for you. Did you get the swing turf mat because foam mats didn't do very much?

[Triniexr]

Hey there - I am one of the owners here at Rain or Shine. We appreciate the interest and were curious of any recommendations you have for expanding the size options.

I'd also be interested in a strip that's 1' x 5'

[cmibobby]

What is the weight of the 5X4 for the Swing Turf and do you have to use double sided tape to keep in place in my garage simulator - I have the 5x4 CCE mat and I did have to use carpet tape to keep it from not moving - I am in my mid 60s and take normal divots and I find that if I hit more than 50 balls in a practice session I do start to get some wrist pain -- Yes and if you hit it the ball really fat you will really feel it in the wrist on the CCE Mat. I was thinking about getting the the Fiberbuilt Mat but only because of the less strain on the wrist but I only hit balls about twice a week for about an hour so I rather find the most realistic mat out there with little less strain on the wrist so that is why I am now considering the Swing Turf mat -- A 5x5 mat would suit my set up a lot better because I have a SkyTrak and this would give me more room to move my Skytrak up or down the mat. Can anybody comment on the comparison between the SwingTurf vs the CCE ?

[myrison]

I’ve had both, the ST is much more forgiving. it also moves around in the garage though. I’ve got an anti slip mat under it but it still moves a bit so I’d count on still needing the carpet tape if you’re on concrete.

[jerry3]

I just emailed Rain or Shine Golf and they are able to create custom hitting strips for very reasonable cost. I bought a 1x2 hitting insert for $25 which is a great deal. Haven't received it yet so can't comment on how much I like it compared to my fiberbuilt but will post once I receive it.

Email below if you're interested in custom sizes...

info@rainorshinegolf.com

[Jkaser]

I’ve now had the ST mat for 2 months. I’ve been playing 54-72 holes a day plus occasionally hitting the range for the last month. I have zero pain (I’m 55) and really love the mat! I find that mis-hits seem to be as expected on the launch monitor. I’m also seeing zero wear after thousands of shots. My friends think the mat is great as well.

[myrison]

I’ve been playing 54-72 holes a day plus occasionally hitting the range for the last month. I have zero pain (I’m 55).

Good god... you must have joints and tendons of steel . I’m younger with the same mat and in good shape generally and my body complains LONG before that much golf. Kudos to you... sounds like you’re having a ton of fun with the Sim setup!

[linkkingx]

Has anybody had a chance to compare this to the EZTee Poly or Hybrid from STI? They seem pretty similar but if I can order a strip of the swingturf in a custom size it'll spare me having to buy a whole mat from STI. The STI distributor near me said they would only sell me a full mat, which I don't need.