Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How to decide?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • How to decide?

    Hello, I am a future new user and have played several simulators before, hence me coming to this site fore advice. I have looked around on here and now there are way too many options to choose from. Haha. I was almost set on an Optishot system but it seems that there are so many more out there. Space is not an issue. My budget is around $4000. If i don't have to spend anywhere near that I would be happy. Any advice would be appreciated.

  • #2
    You can get close to that number with a skytrak or mevo+ setup doing it via diy.

    Comment


    • #3
      For your budget I would highly recommend a Skytrak. I started with a Skytrak and then upgraded to a Uneekor after really getting into sim golf. The Skytrak is great for the money- I was happy with it and the guy who bought it from me has enjoyed it as well.

      Comment


      • #4
        Is Skytrak that much better than Optishot?

        Comment


        • #5
          100% skytrak or Mevo+ is the way to go with the budget available

          Comment


          • #6
            Hey, I'm completely new to this, so take this for what it's worth.

            I've been researching launch monitors in this price range, and it seems the Mevo+ and the SkyTrak are the clear leaders. They go back and forth to me in terms of an edge. However, neither device provides swing data, and I cannot find any add-ons that would provide that. If your budget was around $4k for the device (before the setup of screen, mat, etc), is there an option out there that provides all that the Mevo+ does as well as swing analysis and works well with the top sim software out there?

            Thanks for the thread!

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by 4theDogs View Post
              Is Skytrak that much better than Optishot?
              It's not even a comparison. Skytrak is an actual launch monitor. Meaning that it actually monitors the launch of the ball.

              Optishot is not a launch monitor. It simply uses a sensor to see what the club is doing at impact. Have you ever played the Tiger Woods golf game on the Nintendo Wii? That's basically optishot. You literally don't even need to use a ball to use the Optishot. It's a video game, whereas the Skytrak is an actual launch monitor.

              You can't really compare the two because they are completely different products. And as someone who started with an Optishot before getting a Skytrak, yes, it's a thousand times better.
              Last edited by 3on3putt; 08-17-2020, 02:31 PM.

              Comment


              • 3on3putt
                3on3putt commented
                Editing a comment
                Haha I know what you mean. To your original post, Mevo or Skytrak will make up about half your budget (they are both in the 2k price range). Some ways to keep it under 4k total would be to just hit into a net with a monitor (so you don't have to buy a screen and projector and possibly not a full-blown enclosure either). Although I favor TGC over e6, the Mevo does come equipped with 5 e6 courses so you could save a little money if you were fine with just 5 courses for now. So basically, 2k for Mevo and the 5 courses, under 1k for a refurbished gaming computer, a few hundred bucks for a net and a few hundred on a mat and you can keep it under 4k total.

              • DS12
                DS12 commented
                Editing a comment
                I think the Mevo+ 5 courses are only iOS compatible. The Mevo+ is optimized for iOS right out of the box. To play a sim on a PC, you need to pay more for the sim software

              • bubbtubbs
                bubbtubbs commented
                Editing a comment
                True, but if he has an iOS device already he can wait to do the projection and pc thing a bit longer and still use the unit in the meantime.

                Even if he doesn't, refurbed iPads are pretty cheap - a fraction of the cost of TGC2019 and a rig that'll run it.

            • #8
              If you take your time shopping a ProTee system is possible and it also gives you club data.

              Comment


              • Noob20
                Noob20 commented
                Editing a comment
                I haven't seen much regarding the ProTee system. Trying to research it now.

              • DejaVu
                DejaVu commented
                Editing a comment
                I have the Protee. It's extremely accurate vs real life golf. It requires a little more patience to set up initially, but once it's set up its plug and play. I would definitely not have improved as much with other systems that don't offer club/face data. THE biggest helper imo. Good luck.

            • #9
              I was in the same boat you are in, golf simulator for $4,000 or less. I decided on the Mevo+ as I have the space, comes with the 5 courses (ios only), provides some club data and no annual fees unlike the Skytrak. I also already have the ipad and do not have a PC capable of sim.

              The good news about the 14 week wait on Mevo+ is allowed time to shop and find used projector and impact screen. Should be receiving Mevo+ in 3 weeks.

              Below is my budget and where I am project to date. It looks like I am going to make it under budget, but I am pretty sure there will be a couple unaccounted for items
              actual budget
              Mevo+ (selfie stick, battery pack, metallic stickers) 2115 2000
              Screen direct from mill 0 350
              Projector 220 500
              projector mount 58.85 50
              curtain material 151.6 115
              Curtain rail 108 100
              ceiling protection 25.44 100
              ipad holder 20
              sportscreen 364 400
              Mat 370.78 300
              used screen 13 0
              grommets 3.8 5
              Velcro 9.53 10
              HDMI adapter 44.52 50
              3484.52 4000

              Comment


              • Noob20
                Noob20 commented
                Editing a comment
                How long ago did you order the Mevo+? I'm curious if there are other solutions coming out soon, as the SkyTrak hasn't been updated in awhile, and there have been a few advances.

              • 3on3putt
                3on3putt commented
                Editing a comment
                The Skytrak annual fees are only if you want the "extras" (like various games and practice challenges) or if you want to pair it with sim software. If you just want the driving range, there's no annual fee.

              • xfactor989
                xfactor989 commented
                Editing a comment
                Order June 1, scheduled to ship week of Sept 7th. The 14 week lead time they were advertising on June 1st.

            • #10
              Noob20 - have a look at ProTee, they include club data built in, and there are no annual fees! The trade-offs are only a few: 1.) you have to custom build a stance mat, or your flooring to house an embedded sensor (which is 24" x 12") that measures your club data. 2.) you have to have very specific halogen lighting (mounted in the exact position for measuring ball flight. Most ProTee systems already include the lights, and the cans(to mount them in), 3.) you will need 2 cameras a horizontal & vertical that need to be mounted in position to measure your ball flight after impact (again most ProTee systems, including used) include the cameras/mounting hardware.

              The ProTee sensor hitting mat is the best, it has something like 160 sensors in the mat, more than any other you will find. It is also one of the first to come out, so it's been through a lot, and updated many times.

              Comment


              • xfactor989
                xfactor989 commented
                Editing a comment
                Another good option, but my understanding this would need to be a permanent setup. I need to keep my garage a garage, so will be taking down every time.

              • Brettster
                Brettster commented
                Editing a comment
                ProTee is not always a permanent setup. (it can be, if you want it)

                I bought a used ProTee from someone that had it mounted in his garage, he sent me a video showing the entire setup lifting up to his garage wall when he had to use his garage. There are others up here that can comment on this type of setup as well.

            • #11
              Thank you everybody for the info. This has been very helpful so far. This is why i joined this group, to get info from real users. Although, I have never hear of Mevo. I will do some research.
              Last edited by 4theDogs; 08-17-2020, 10:57 PM.

              Comment


              • bubbtubbs
                bubbtubbs commented
                Editing a comment
                Make sure it's Mevo+. Regular Mevo came out a year or two ago and doesn't have sim capability.

              • Brettster
                Brettster commented
                Editing a comment
                Hows putting with Mevo+? Also, do you require 16'-20' of ball flight for the radar of Mevo+ to measure properly?

              • Noob20
                Noob20 commented
                Editing a comment
                Brettster, indoors they require 8' of ball flight, recommend 10'+ for the Mevo+.
            Working...
            X