Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Build Summary & Review After 18 Months

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Build Summary & Review After 18 Months

    I started my build in April 2018 after months of planning and scouring this forum. It took 6 months until I was playing and then another 6 months to iron out a number of key issues. I’ve now been using the sim for a year, fine tuning some items, and I wanted to share my learnings in the hope that I can give back for some of the help all the other forum members gave (and continue to give) me.

    There are a few photos attached to this post. For anyone interested, there are more photos showing the construction, finished room and some close-ups here: https://app.box.com/s/b81xr65qr6loa1qnoi85u5om01suteqq

    My build is a full room build inside my workshop and is primarily used as a golf sim room and gym, with the additional options of media room and racing sim.

    Build Summary:
    • Interior Dimensions: 15’ x 26’ (15’ wide. Length: 18” behind screen, 13.5’ of usable putting surface plus 11’ of gym flooring)
    • Screen: Par2Pro Custom SQ Screen 8’ 9” high and 14’ wide. Plus custom built padded surround. Additional DirectFromTheMill backup screen mounted behind the main screen plus memory foam mattress in hitting area to reduce bounce back.
    • Putting surface: NP50 from STI
    • Hitting Mats: Divot Action. Plus 2 x Fiberbuilt Interlocking Fairway Mats
    • Projector: Panasonic PT-VZ580
    • Audio: Pioneer VSX-831 receiver with Polk Audio RM6750 5.1 surround sound speakers
    • Computer Hardware: Dell XPS 8930 with i7-8700 6-Core Processor and NVIDIA® GeForce® GTX 1070
    • Computer OS: Windows 8.1 (see notes below)
    • Sim Software: FSX2020 (upgraded from 2018) and TGC 2019 (Upgraded from TGC)
    • Keyboard Solutions: Air Keyboard iPad solution for both FSX and TGC
    • Sim Hardware: CPO GC2a
    • Video: 2 x 1080p Full HD 120fps High Speed OV2710 CMOS Mini Box USB Web Camera 2.1mm Lens
    Costs:
    • Construction Cost (materials, fasteners, electrical, lighting, etc): $11,000
    • Labour (Framing, Electrical, Drywall Tape & Mud, Painting, Pair Of Hands!): $3,700
    • Simulator Cost (GC2 (CPO), shield, software (FSX &TGC), hitting mats, impact screens (x2), projector, screen trim, computer, putting turf, hole cups, cabinet): $20,000
    • Audio Cost: $900
    • Racing Sim Cost: $600
    • Total: $36,200
    • All $’s in CAD$
    Key Notes & Learnings

    1) Space
    The more space the better! I am very lucky to have such a large custom built space and I still wish I had more room. If in doubt, go bigger!

    2) SubFloor
    After research on the forum, I built my subfloor with three key things in mind: insulation (to reduce hydro bills and sound), depth to install putting cups, and being able to have a sunken area (4’ x 8’) for both stance and hitting mats, which then enables me to install solutions with different heights and lower or raise them to ensure that both my original install and future customizations are all at the same final height

    3) Hitting Mat
    I have a combination of a Divot Action (purchased) and Fiberbuilt panels. Neither causes issues with my elbow. I find the Divot Action is better for higher calibre players and players who “pick” the ball, whilst the Fiberbuilt panels are great for higher handicappers and “diggers”. I feel it can be a bit too "forgiving" for real practice. My plan is to build a custom divot action using gel pad, to try and minimize the variation between the hitting mat and the surrounding surface which happens after a few “heavier” shots.

    4) Lighting
    I have my overhead lighting in three “banks”. One bank in the gym area, one above the hitting area and one near the screen. All are on dimmer switches, which means I can adjust all the room lighting depending on use.

    5) Hardware
    I LOVE my GC2. My regular playing partner is the assistant pro at my local course and he is very impressed with the accuracy of it (it's well documented how good players trust it). One day I may investigate Uneekor a bit further, with the primary benefits of club data and optional left handed play, but for the time being I am very happy with the GC2.

    6) Software
    I have both TGC2019 and FSX2020. It is widely recorded on this forum, but in my opinion FSX is an awesome tool for practice and club fitting, whilst TGC is superior in terms of game play (both in terms of graphics, but also some key aspects of multi player, putting and other elements of game play). Having both is an ideal combo.

    7) Putting Surface
    I am very pleased with my NP50 putting surface from STI. You will see from the photos, that it is also my stance area. It may be difficult to see, but after 18 months of use it is starting to show signs of wear in the stance area. I had expected this, and with the variable height sub floor build, when this finally becomes too worn, I will have the option to replace it with a new 4x4 section of NP50, or another, harder wearing stance mat.

    8) Windows OS
    My computer came with Windows 10 installed.

    I had an endless stream of connectivity issues and thought I had found a series of solutions, which I posted here: https://golfsimulatorforum.com/forum...ting-solutions

    Despite this giving me a working system, I still had connectivity issues until I finally took the advice of mthunt and “downgraded” to Windows 8.1 and turned off ALL windows updates. Since that change, I have had ZERO issues (knock on wood) . IMHO I am 100% confident that the issues that people report and complain about being TGC / Protee server issues, are all related to Windows updates and issues which can be solved by getting away from Windows 10.

    9) Cabinet
    The cabinet is an IKEA hack. I bought IKEA Besta cabinets and then customized them with two doors built with speaker cloth, to house the sub woofer and the computer (for ventilation). I also installed an AC infinity airplane T7 to help with cooling. The drawer is customized for the keyboard and mouse.

    10) Golf #1
    If you are a keen golfer, don’t spend too much time or $’s investing in other toys unless you have a stack of time on your hands. I built the sim racer with the idea that I would want to have options…. But practicing and playing golf fills up all of my spare time and the sim racer tends to sit there getting dusty (although it is awesome when it does occasionally get used)!

    THANKS
    There are many people I would like to thank for their help in me getting this build done.
    • Everyone who contributes to this forum for a start.
    • @Par2Pro for their fantastic customer service and help
    • @BWJones and aja for their help with speakers and surround sound
    • @wbond gnomike and cspin for all their help with the putting surface information
    • @dbgolf72 for his work on the direct from the mill screen
    • @mthunt for all his input throughout the forum and for the carpet tiles idea
    • @snaphook and @birdie4me for their feedback and recommendations on the Panasonic PT-VZ 580 projector
    • @friendBOMBER and mthunt and all the other designers who have created courses for us to enjoy
    • Plus my wife for allowing me to build this and Brent, the assistant pro, who helped with ideas and suggestions throughout the build.
    • Plus a couple of friends who worked at “mates rates” to help me with the construction and electrical.
    I hope this post provides some useful information for people starting new builds. If you have any questions, I’ll do my best to help.
    Last edited by GoldenSim; 04-08-2020, 09:50 PM.

  • #2
    GoldenSim wow, thanks so much for the post, looks fantastic.

    Question on the projector. This is not a short throw correct? how far from screen and do you see shadows. Looks like its quite a bit b behind the hitting area.

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Hey SuperTimo - Thanks. You're right, I don't think the PT-VZ 850 is considered short throw. I have it mounted 184" (15' 4") from the screen (i.e. the front of the projector) and 112" from the floor to the centre of the lens (my ceiling is 10' high and with the projector mount it sits down this far). If I stand at the front of my stance mat (9' from the screen) and stand upright, I can see a shadow of the very top of my head (I'm 6' 1" tall). As soon as I take my stance (which is obviously lower than full height) I do not see a shadow. I was very worried about this during the spec phase and I have never even noticed a shadow during sim use.

  • #3
    Thanks for putting this out there. Really impressed with your build!

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Thanks! It took time to research, build and troubleshoot, but I'm stoked I built it. With COVID-19 shutting down our course for who knows how long, and with long winters here, it's nice to be able to play all year!

  • #4
    GoldenSim It’s a great space you’ve created there. When you say “long winters here,” where are you talking about?

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Golden, BC, Canada - we've still got snow on the ground here

    • tron
      tron commented
      Editing a comment
      My wife and I are big fans of BC. Enjoy your new sim room!

  • #5
    Great write up and thanks for the info. This is so useful for everyone. Couple of questions:

    1) Do you recall the cost/size of the memory foam mattress behind the screen?
    2) Are you seeing any discoloration from where the balls are hitting the screen?

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      I got the memory foam used on Kijiji. I wouldn't typically buy a used mattress (!) but just for this use I figured it was OK. The seller assured me that the cover was washed. I paid $100 CAD for it. If the projector is not on, I see ballmarks on the screen. But when the projector is on, I can't see anything.

  • #6
    Nice clean room my man. Well done.
    My Courses:
    World Par 3's by mthunt
    Toronto GC (L) mthunt
    Burlington G&CC by mthunt
    Weston G&CC by mthunt
    London Hunt Club L mthunt
    Park CC Lidar mthunt
    Sunningdale GC Robinson L
    Sunningdale GC Thompson L
    Muirfield Village (liDAR) First Ever Lidar course
    Country Club of Castle Pines (liDAR)
    The Sanctuary GC ProTee L
    The National GC L mthunt
    Mississaugua GC L mthunt
    Shaughnessy G&CC L mthunt
    Markland Woods CC mthunt
    Hidden Lake Old L mthunt
    Magna GC L mthunt
    Barrie CC L mthunt
    mthunt Range

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Perfect. Thank you as always. Is the straight putt feature only for Skytrack? Or are you still using 2% for GC2?

    • mthunt
      mthunt commented
      Editing a comment
      All tour players have the option of straight putt and adjustment of settings up or down by 5%

    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      OK - thanks. I noticed that Q School is at your great version of The National this weekend, so if I have time, I’ll try and figure everything out and play that. If not I’ll join one of the societies this week. Thanks for the input

  • #7
    It looks like my room with the carpet on the wall. I like it.
    My Courses:
    World Par 3's by mthunt
    Toronto GC (L) mthunt
    Burlington G&CC by mthunt
    Weston G&CC by mthunt
    London Hunt Club L mthunt
    Park CC Lidar mthunt
    Sunningdale GC Robinson L
    Sunningdale GC Thompson L
    Muirfield Village (liDAR) First Ever Lidar course
    Country Club of Castle Pines (liDAR)
    The Sanctuary GC ProTee L
    The National GC L mthunt
    Mississaugua GC L mthunt
    Shaughnessy G&CC L mthunt
    Markland Woods CC mthunt
    Hidden Lake Old L mthunt
    Magna GC L mthunt
    Barrie CC L mthunt
    mthunt Range

    Comment


    • Jay28
      Jay28 commented
      Editing a comment
      Brilliant. Thank you.
      I was going to go down the padded tile route for walls and ceiling, but I think I am leaing towards the carpet tiles.
      One quick further question on the carpet tiles... what width are they?
      cheers.

    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Hi Jay28 - I think the padded sections would look amazing, but I'm pretty certain they'll cost more and are also more prone to marks and damage. The nice thing about dark carpet tile is that it's designed to not show anything! My tiles are 24" square which is a pretty standard size. When I sourced them, there were a few other sizes, but these were used (taken out of a commercial building) and the right price!

    • Jay28
      Jay28 commented
      Editing a comment
      Cheers for that.
      I've found some tiles 50cm by 50cm and 8mm thick.
      I can stick and crown staple them.
      My build is slightly different as it's not up against the walls on either side, but a full frame made of wood and then internally fitted with plywood.

  • #8
    Amazing room GoldenSim! What is that club rack you have?

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Thanks a lot. The club racks were donated from my local golf club. I’m not sure if they’re available for retail customers. I think golf courses probably get them from the club manufacturers. It might be worth asking at a golf course or retail store...

  • #9
    Gotta love the Hoop on the wall - Chipping practice?

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Haha - no, if I know what you're looking at, that's for gym equipment. I WISH my chipping was that accurate

  • #10
    Really great job on your room, looks great and the racing sim looks like a lot of fun as well!

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Thanks Dax - yep - when I have the time, which is rare, it's nice to burn some laps in it. It's pretty amazing how far technology has come since I was a kid. Being able to play golf and go racing in a room is pretty nice!

  • #11
    That is awesome. The best part though is the sim gym simulator rules and rule number 10.

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Thanks wbond - and thanks again for your help back when I was building it. That rule was really my reason for posting that in the gallery for you guys. I figured some of you would appreciate it. You've gotta love spending $35k and then your mate comes over, bitches about spending $10 for a round, and then tells you "you know what you should do... you should put a fully stocked bar and some recliners in here. I know you don't drink, but it would be good for us" LOL

  • #12
    Dude, what a great write up and also congrats on a fantastic sim build! You're so right about having a sim during these weird covid times. Crisis? What crisis? j/k I shouldn't joke about it, I know, but it does make a difference having the sim if you have to spend more time cooped up inside!

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Hey Mike - I hope you're well. Thanks for the props. As you know, there were certainly some challenges making decisions, and then getting everything purchased, installed, and mostly working reliably. Now that it does, it's SO nice having a working setup. It's torturing a couple of my friends who usually come over and play rounds during the winter that they can't play right now. We had a trip to Bandon planned for the end of March which had to be postponed and having the sim is about the only thing that made it bearable!

  • #13
    The room is amazing. Well done.
    Im looking at the same projector. Can you tell me why you chose it?

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      It was a combination of research on the forum, feedback and research on the projector sites. Great image for sim golf as well as movies etc, projection size was what I needed from the distance I had, and price was right. Really happy with it.

  • #14
    Amazing build. Well done!

    Comment


    • GoldenSim
      GoldenSim commented
      Editing a comment
      Thanks for the props. I couldn't have done it without a lot of help from everyone here

  • #15
    That room looks great GoldenSim . I'm building about the exact same size room, except the ceiling will be between 11.5' and 12' high. How much of the vertical lens shift are you using on your projector? I'm looking at the same projector and hoping that if its mounted that high the lens shift can move it down to fill the screen.
    Thanks for any help you can give!

    Comment

    Working...
    X