Tie Breakers

[Maverick]

In the event of a tie, either in a regular tournament or in a match play round. 4 choices:

1: Divide the hdcps by 2 and round down, then play the front 9. If still tie, play the back 9. Repeat if needed.

2: Start at hole #1 and play 3 holes. Continue on the next 3 holes if needed, and so on...etc..
The difference in hdcp will determine how many strokes to give to the higher hdcp player(for each 3 holes). Use the following method:

If difference is 1-3, then give 0 stroke.
If 4-6, give 1 stroke.
If 7-10, give 2 strokes.
If 11-15, give 3 strokes.
If 16 and above, give 4 strokes.

3: 3 hole playoff using #2's method. Play 16th, 17th, and 18th. If still tie, then use the scorecard from the original round, starting at #1 hdcp hole. Use hdcp accordingly.

4: Use the scorecard. Start at #1 hdcp hole.

Thoughts?

[bcgc0918]

You use the #1 HDCP hole on the index. Meaning the hardest hole on the course. Not the #1 hole.

[Maverick]

In the event of a tie, either in a regular tournament or in a match play round. 4 choices:

1: Divide the hdcps by 2 and round down, then play the front 9. If still tie, play the back 9. Repeat if needed.

2: Start at hole #1 and play 3 holes. Continue on the next 3 holes if needed, and so on...etc..
The difference in hdcp will determine how many strokes to give to the higher hdcp player(for each 3 holes). Use the following method:

If difference is 1-3, then give 0 stroke.
If 4-6, give 1 stroke.
If 7-10, give 2 strokes.
If 11-15, give 3 strokes.
If 16 and above, give 4 strokes.

3: 3 hole playoff using #2's method. Play 16th, 17th, and 18th. If still tie, then use the scorecard from the original round, starting at #1 hdcp hole. Use hdcp accordingly.

4: Use the scorecard. Start at #1 hdcp hole.

Thoughts?

[bcgc0918]

Scorecard meaning you will go up the 2 players card from hole#1 until someone beats the other? If so I vote for this but in reverse. I think it should be the last hole that's the first tiebreaker. That way everyone knows to finish strong if they think they are in a good position.

Sorry should have explained it this way

if the image posts corectly hole 5 is #1 HDCP (index)if still tied then go to #2 HDCP (index) hole. This indicates the degree of difficulty of each hole for any given course. So your tie is broken on the hardest holes for each course.

[HWoods]

Majors should be a 3 hole playoff. Regular events can be scorecard with hardest holes first. That's my vote.

[Maverick]

I like this one.

[Maverick]

Majors should be a 3 hole playoff. Regular events can be scorecard with hardest holes first. That's my vote.

I like this one, but lets just go with the scorecard. It's the easiest one for everybody. No need to schedule a 3 hole match, set up time, fire up the sim, etc...

It's quick and easy to do. Don't have to wait a week to find out who won.

[THARN]

Have not had a tie yet and this is our second year. But we've been adding more players each week.

So, you are voting for #3, THARN?

yes- # 3