Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

New Home Build Simulator - Need Advise ASAP!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • New Home Build Simulator - Need Advise ASAP!

    I'll say this first, the framers are wrapping up framer our house in the next day or two, so answer quick answers would be very beneficial. This whole thing has me stressed!

    Here's where I'm at:

    We are building a new home and had a simulator planning in the basement. The area it was suppose on was a wall 14' wide by 10' tall in the basement. Perfect spot, over looks the living room area which has a 133" screen for games and stuff. Anyway, our architect messed something up big time because we only have about 10' in depth before the ceiling drop to 6' for HVAC ducting. They can't move it at this point.

    So, it seems the only way to make this work is to push the wall back, but I can't push the whole wall back unfortunately as part of it goes to an exterior wall. See the photo.

    Click image for larger version  Name:	simluator-area.jpg Views:	0 Size:	68.2 KB ID:	223024

    The new area is 10' 10" wide and 6' deep.


    My main questions are:
    • How close is the closet you can be to the screen? Thinking MAYBE I could still fit it in the original area, but you'd have to be 7' from the screen. Doesn't seem like that will work.
    • If we have to push it back, it seems like I can fit a 4:3 8'x10.5' bay perfectly into this set back area. Will it suck having a 4:3 set up?
    • I was thinking of the Foresight system with the FSX 2018 software and GC2. Can this run at 4:3 even?
    • Is it OK to have only a foot of space behind the impact screen? Since this area can only be 6' deep, that's all I can have.
    Other things I'd like to figure out:
    • It seems like I can "build" this system myself instead of getting everything from Foresight for $40,000 (now that I've went through all this that price seems a little crazy)
    • I've been reading on this forum, seem like there are many configuration options and different monitors with different software.
    • I was thinking of getting https://shop.foresightsports.com/col...ox-par-package and then my own screen, projector, etc. to finalize my set up.
    • After reading more I've considered the SkyTrak instead of GS2 and ProTee looks like a lot of fun. I could run ProTee with SkyTrak, correct?
    Any feedback on screen size, launch monitors, etc. would be EXTREMELY HELPFUL and much much appreciated. There is so many options its just a bit overwhelming!
    Last edited by JustinTS33; 10-20-2019, 04:52 PM.

  • #2
    1-Some people are as close as 7' maybe even a touch closer. The farther back you are the better though better aesthetics and probably less screen wear as well
    2-4:3 is fine if that's what you have to work with. I used this for quite a while and it was fine. Is 16:9 better, absolutely, but if you don't have the room it's a moot point.
    3-You need to answer what you really want the sim for, FSX is overpriced, and most would agree.
    4-A foot behind is perfect, i would say the majority of setups have this, some have less though.
    5-Definitely build yourself, it's not hard and doesn't take any special tools. You will save a ton.
    6-There are different software options available and most work with GC2 even though foresight would like you to believe otherwise.
    7-You can put together a package cheaper than that option
    8-Skytrak is very good for the price, GC2 is better for many reasons. Whether the cost difference is acceptable is up to you. Are you talking about the protee software or hardware. TGC works with both GC2 and skytrak. For skytrak you must purchase it from skytrak. For GC2 you get if from protee or even used from someone else with a transfer fee. If it's hardware, it is a more involved setup and takes some tweaking, but it comes out well for most when it's done.

    Last edited by wbond; 10-21-2019, 05:25 PM.

    Comment


    • JustinTS33
      JustinTS33 commented
      Editing a comment
      I was thinking the CG2 or SkyTrak with TGC (protee) software.

  • #3
    Your ceiling height is dropping from 10' to 6' for HVAC ducting? That doesn't sound right. They should be able to put HVAC ducting in 1' or less of vertical space, so you'd drop a 10' ceiling to 9'. Unless there is something that drops the natural ceiling to 7' and they are taking it down to 6' from there? Which doesn't make sense. I can't imagine why an architect would design a 6' ceiling anywhere in a new house or how that would be up to code (unless maybe it is sloped due to roof pitch??).

    Having just finished building a house, it is really frustrating how little architects typically consider HVAC and the required ducting in their plans. However, I'm guessing, if you push and push, there is possibly another place to put your ducting. Even if the framers don't like it...it maybe require some more time and money though. Good luck!


    Comment


    • JustinTS33
      JustinTS33 commented
      Editing a comment
      It drops to 8', sorry about that. Still too low to swing. I want to have them move it, but its nearly impossible. Hard to describe that whole situation here.

  • #4
    I think I'd be more concerned with the width of the room. How wide is the area going to be where you will swing your club? I agree with wbond with the other dimensions (I have exactly 1' behind my screen and I'm about 7' from the screen with no issues). I have Just a little over 13' of width and I"m about 6" - 1' offset from the middle (depending on where I set up the skytrak unit). I know that 14' is the minimum to hit from the middle and 15-18' is desired (especially if you're going to invite Lefties.

    You also may want to check out the Uneekor system as it is very favorably reviewed by many on this site (see gene438 's excellent review here: https://golfsimulatorforum.com/forum...stem-my-review).

    If it helps, this is what 13W X 9'6" H looks like with hitting zone 7' from the screen (sorry about the wires, I'm getting ready to install the Uneekor on Wednesday so I'm doing some remodeling!!). Screen is 12X9. Good Luck with your build.

    Click image for larger version

Name:	golf room.jpg
Views:	1323
Size:	214.8 KB
ID:	223134

    --
    What Could Possibly Go Wrong?

    Comment


    • Brettster
      Brettster commented
      Editing a comment
      Thanks for the pic Mike, that's probably about exactly what I'm going to end up with. We bought a new house 4 months ago which has a 16' x 12' shed (shingled and rafter built gambrel roof gives me an 11' height across about 8' of width. The shed is sided and has a garage door on one end (on the 12' width, so in appearance almost like a garage - with a poured concrete floor, unfinished inside.

      I may have some questions for you as a I start planning the installation - as I'm also considering Uneekor ceiling mount.

  • #5
    I do have plenty of width. about 16' or so. Also the wall on the left is open, just a little half wall (which I could take out if I wanted, but don't think I need to.) It really makes me mad that our architect messed this up and now I may have to go with a 10.5 x 8 screen. It seems like that is very small compared to what everyone is using and especially small when I planned on it being 14' wide originally.

    Comment


    • #6
      This is how narrow my small garage area is. I'm 5'8 and my daughter is 5'3 and have zero issues with wall contact.

      Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_4598.JPG
Views:	761
Size:	102.1 KB
ID:	224241

      Comment


      • #7
        10ft nice ProTee set up Right Hand only

        Attached Files

        Comment

        Working...
        X